Common Myths About Health Sharing

This post may contain affiliate links, which means if you enroll through my link, I’ll receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Health sharing plans, also known as healthcare sharing plans, are becoming increasingly popular as an alternative to traditional health insurance. However, many myths and misconceptions still surround these plans, causing confusion and uncertainty. This article aims to debunk the most common myths about health sharing plans, providing a clearer understanding of how they work and why they might be a good choice for you.

Myth 1: Health Sharing Plans Are the Same as Health Insurance

Myth: Health sharing plans are just another form of health insurance.

Reality: Health sharing plans are not insurance. Instead, they are a way for like-minded individuals to share medical expenses. Unlike insurance, health sharing plans do not guarantee payment of medical bills. Members voluntarily contribute to a pool of funds used to pay for eligible medical expenses of other members.

Health sharing plans operate on principles of shared responsibility and community support, often aligning with specific religious or ethical values. While they can help manage healthcare costs, they do not provide the same regulatory protections or guarantees as traditional health insurance.

Myth 2: Health Sharing Plans Are Unreliable and Don’t Pay Claims

Myth: Health sharing plans often fail to pay medical bills, leaving members with unpaid claims.

Reality: Health sharing plans have a strong track record of sharing eligible medical expenses. However, it’s crucial to understand that they operate differently from insurance. Each health share organization has specific guidelines and requirements for sharing expenses. Members must adhere to these guidelines to ensure their medical bills are eligible for sharing.

Most reputable health sharing plans are transparent about their processes and have systems in place to manage the sharing of expenses effectively. It’s important to read and understand the membership guidelines thoroughly to avoid any misunderstandings.

Myth 3: Health Sharing Plans Are Only for the Very Healthy

Myth: Only extremely healthy individuals can join health sharing plans.

Reality: While some health sharing plans may have restrictions regarding pre-existing conditions, they are not exclusively for the super healthy. Many health sharing plans do accept individuals with pre-existing conditions but may impose waiting periods or limitations on sharing expenses related to those conditions.

Some health sharing plans offer special programs or incentives for members to improve their health, encouraging a healthier lifestyle rather than excluding those with health issues. It’s important to review the specific terms of each health sharing plan to understand how pre-existing conditions are handled.

Myth 4: Health Sharing Plans Don’t Cover Major Medical Expenses

Myth: Health sharing plans won’t help with significant medical expenses, such as surgeries or hospital stays.

Reality: Health sharing plans often cover major medical expenses, including surgeries, hospital stays, and emergency care. However, coverage depends on the specific plan and its guidelines. Many health sharing plans have high sharing limits, sometimes up to millions of dollars, to help members manage substantial medical costs.

It’s crucial to review the sharing limits, exclusions, and guidelines of any health sharing plan to understand what is covered and what isn’t. Some plans may have annual or per-incident sharing caps, so it’s important to choose a plan that meets your needs.

Myth 5: Health Sharing Plans Are Not Regulated

Myth: Health sharing plans operate without any oversight or regulation.

Reality: While health sharing plans are not regulated in the same way as traditional insurance, they are not entirely without oversight. Many health sharing ministries are accountable to their members and adhere to internal guidelines and standards.

Additionally, health sharing ministries that qualify as 501(c)(3) organizations are subject to federal regulations governing non-profit organizations. They must operate transparently and report financial information to maintain their non-profit status.

Myth 6: Health Sharing Plans Are Expensive

Myth: Health sharing plans are just as expensive, if not more so, than traditional health insurance.

Reality: Health sharing plans are often more affordable than traditional health insurance. Members typically pay a monthly share amount that is generally lower than the premiums for comparable health insurance plans. Additionally, many health sharing plans have lower out-of-pocket costs, such as deductibles and copayments.

However, costs can vary depending on the specific health sharing plan and the level of sharing selected. It’s important to compare the costs and benefits of health sharing plans with traditional insurance to determine the best option for your needs.

Myth 7: Health Sharing Plans Don’t Offer Preventive Care

Myth: Health sharing plans do not cover preventive care services.

Reality: Many health sharing plans do provide for preventive care services, though coverage can vary. Some plans include preventive services such as wellness visits, vaccinations, and screenings as part of their sharing guidelines.

It’s important to check the specific benefits offered by each health sharing plan to understand what preventive care services are covered. Some plans may have additional programs or incentives to encourage preventive care and healthy living.

Myth 8: Health Sharing Plans Are Not Accepted by Most Doctors

Myth: Most doctors and healthcare providers do not accept health sharing plans.

Reality: Health sharing plans are typically accepted by a wide range of healthcare providers. Because they are not insurance, members usually pay for services out-of-pocket and then submit receipts for reimbursement according to the plan’s guidelines.

Many healthcare providers are familiar with health sharing plans and understand the process. However, it’s always a good idea to inform your healthcare provider about your health sharing membership and discuss payment options in advance.

Myth 9: Health Sharing Plans Don’t Offer Prescription Drug Coverage

Myth: Health sharing plans do not help with the cost of prescription medications.

Reality: Many health sharing plans provide some level of assistance with prescription drug costs, though the specifics can vary. Some plans offer discount programs or partner with pharmacies to provide lower-cost medications to members.

It’s essential to review the prescription drug benefits of each health sharing plan to understand what is covered and how to access those benefits. Some plans may have limitations or require members to use specific pharmacies to receive discounts.

Myth 10: Health Sharing Plans Are Not Compatible with the ACA

Myth: Health sharing plans do not comply with the Affordable Care Act (ACA) requirements and are not a valid alternative.

Reality: Health sharing plans are not subject to ACA regulations because they are not considered insurance. However, they are recognized as a legitimate alternative to traditional insurance. Members of qualified health sharing ministries were exempt from the ACA’s individual mandate penalty, which was in place until 2019.

Many people choose health sharing plans because they align with their values and provide a cost-effective alternative to ACA-compliant health insurance plans. It’s important to understand that while health sharing plans offer many benefits, they do not provide the same protections and guarantees as ACA-compliant insurance.

Final Thoughts

Now that we’ve debunked these myths, it’s evident that health sharing plans offer a fantastic alternative to traditional health insurance.

They provide an affordable solution that empowers members to tailor their healthcare to fit their specific needs. The flexibility of these plans makes them a practical and attractive option for many families.

Before joining a health sharing plan, carefully review the guidelines, benefits, and costs to ensure it meets your needs. Health sharing plans can offer significant savings and community support, but they require a thorough understanding to use effectively.